Is a LA-200 active audio loop amplifier a good choice for amplifying VLF loop antennas for SID detection?

If by “LA-200” you mean the common audio induction-loop amplifier units (such as the Sarabec LA-200), then no — it is generally not a good choice as a front-end amplifier for VLF loop antennas used in SID monitoring.

The main reasons are:

  • SID monitoring is usually around 15–30 kHz (e.g. NAA on 24.0 kHz, DHO38 on 23.4 kHz)
  • Most hearing-loop amplifiers are designed for audio-band magnetic loops, not ultra-low-noise RF/VLF reception
  • Their input impedance, filtering, and AGC are usually unsuitable for weak VLF radio signals
  • Many have limited bandwidth below ~50 Hz–20 kHz audio ranges and may roll off or distort the phase response near the frequencies you care about

A proper VLF active loop preamp should instead have:

  • Very low input noise
  • High magnetic-field sensitivity
  • High dynamic range
  • Minimal AGC/compression
  • Good rejection of electric-field mains noise
  • Stable gain at 20–30 kHz

For SID detection, the usual successful approaches are:

  1. Resonant passive loop + sound card
  2. Loop + JFET/FET high-impedance preamp
  3. Differential magnetic loop amplifier
  4. Mini-whip style active antenna (less ideal in noisy urban environments)

Small magnetic loops are widely used for VLF because they reject local electric-field noise better than whips.

For SuperSID-style systems, a large tuned loop (often 1–2 m square) with a dedicated low-noise preamp is usually superior.

A better match for your radio astronomy/SID work would be something along these lines:

  • High-turn passive loop into USB sound card
  • INA-based differential preamp
  • PA0RDT-derived active loop (modified for VLF)
  • Airspy HF+ Discovery directly on a resonant loop
  • A simple J310/JFET source-follower at the antenna

The key issue at VLF is usually noise, not lack of raw gain. Too much broadband amplification often makes SID reception worse by amplifying:

  • mains harmonics
  • switch-mode PSU hash
  • LED lighting noise
  • Ethernet/Raspberry Pi noise

A tuned loop with moderate gain is often much cleaner than a high-gain active amplifier.

By Admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.